Hi Phil,
Nice to see you caught!
Hadn't thought of suggesting Upper Roddleston to you, on the other thread.
It's a funny place, and due to the number of walkers, guess it's like being in a gold fish bowl when your out in a boat!
I walked around the 3 reservoirs in the summer with my wife and daughter, but when trying to find it, we initially ended up in the hills - miles above the lakes, and only found it by parking in Abbey Village, and walking in along the first reservoir, only to then discover - it's quite a long walk around all 3 lakes.
From what I remember, finding the access road and getting to the parking area would be like looking for a needle in a haystack.
Anyway, nice to see you caught!