Quote:
Originally Posted by daniport
Has anyone tried the the Siman 10" nymph rod and is do how does it compare to the Hends range or the greys XF2/XF2+ or the guideline Fario?
I ask as I want to buy a 10"+ nymphing rod but i cant try before i buy as I travel a lot.
Any comments will be very helpful
Many thanks
|
I have been fortunate enough to be able to test out the Jan Siman 2/3 10ft rod by Joel at
www.tungsten-beads-plus.com and be able to compare it to the mk1 10ft 3 streamflex and the mk2 xf2 same size.
Firstly the xf2 is no where near as good as the mk1 streamflex in my opinion. I have had the mk1 since the 3 weight became available and it transformed my fishing with the ease it allows you to fish french nymph technique. I use a hends camou 9m leader and gave been able to fish the whole lot out with this rod wet and dry! I tried the xf2 and after only 30 mins of fishing didnt like it the tip seemed too soft and just didnt have any control casting the camou leader. The rod dynamics seem to have changed greatly the mk1 seems very through action and the xf2 is all tip.
I then got chance to try the Siman 2/3 on a trip out with Joel recently. I used the same 9m camou leader and 2 2.5mm tungsten bead flies that I had done in the morning on my streamflex. The rod cast the setup excellently it seemed to give a very natural fluid motion feel like the streamflex has come to give me. The rod is very light in the hand lighter than the streamflex and a thicker handle which I liked as I struggled in the past with the streamflex grip and made a post about it. When playing a fish the rod was great the tip subdues all the bouncing and shaking of the fight whilst the butt allows you to lean into the fish and get them in suprising for a 2/3. The rod is so good at subduing the fish I had the drag set so you could pull line off easily with finger and thumb no effort yet the fish (11-14 inch) took no line from the reel the rod did all the work!
I am very tempted to upgrade my streamflex as this rod seemed to excell playing the fish I have lost fish before on the streamflex due to the through bend action not cushioning the thrashing but the Siman was very confidence inspiring especially with the drag set so low and none being taken showed no harsh pressure was on the line.
I recommend you have a word with Joel
Jonathan