I've also had that problem with some Partridge light guage patterns, barbless and barbed. I don't use them now, only the heavy wire patterns. Just checked the Grip pattern I have used and its 11011BL, which looks identical to a Tiemco pattern. KDH/Arthur Wellesley gave me a barbless elk hair sedge pattern back in May for use on rivers up in Cumbria as top fly on a duo set up. I think that was tied on the Tiemco pattern I am thinking of. Anyway, over three days, that one fine wire fly/hook took probably 25-30 river brownies up to 1.5lb and also half a dozen bigger, hard pulling rainbows from Watendlath when I fished it dry there! I kept using it to see how long it would last, fully expected it to straighten on the rainbows, especially as some of the takes were very violent, but no, I was well impressed. I think the very sharp, inturned barbless point drives the hook in, giving a deep, strong hold, maybe even stronger on a proper hook-up than a barbed pattern with a straight point.
Picking on the comment about coarse/carp barbless hooks - yes - some excellent, very strong heavyweight patterns - try the ESP Raptors, you could tow a car with a size 10! Very sharp too.
__________________
Last edited by JeffR; 01-09-2010 at 06:24 PM.
|