[quote=shrek;719982]
Quote:
Originally Posted by andreb
Your casting arm shouldnt experience strain on any rod, regardless of length or line weight.
A longer rod gives greater leverage, so it will fatigue your arm quicker.
I will give you the point on river fishing, but not the boat fishing 
|
It's not the length of the rod, or the leverage that causes fatigue, but innefficient casting that does. Any rod, or any action will cause fatigue over time casting. Humans get fatigeud, and that is a fact. A smooth efficient casting action will help prevent fatigue and give the angler greater endurance. You will find that a good caster will be able to go on for hiours, long after someone who believes he has to force the cast, regardless if the rod is 9 or 10 feet long.
I fish stillwaters from a boat with both a 9 foot 6wt Z-Axis, and a 10 foot 6 wt Z-Axis, and I am of the opinion that the 10 footter is more efficient.
In terms of fishing a 20 foot leader from a boat, with three flies spaced 4 feet apart, there is unquestionable a difference in leader managment. The longer rod just makes it a little easier fishing the hang, and lifting the flies out to get the next cast loaded. Regarding the type of drift fishing I do, where two anglers are sitting side by side, both casting in the same direction, the littler extra height makes life slightly more comfortable.
I agree in a very strong wind from behind, the longer rod can be a disadvantage, due to the absence of load on the back cast. but in wind like this, fishing becomes uncomfortable anyway.