gut feeling or confidence

[sabalos]

hi, just a quick poll to see what you all think.
below are photos of two flies , just need to know which you think will be most effective. all things being as equal as possible!

fly a.


fly b.http://www.flyforums.co.uk/members/s...2780-ps10a.jpg

and c. both rubbish

[SharkeyP]

I'd say neither are rubbish, both would catch. The first better in still-waters the second better on rivers, but would probably work on still-waters too in a buzzer hatch.

So a slight bias towards 'b' but 'horses for courses' and all that!

SharkeyP

[3lbgrayling]

I do not think you are doing yourself any favours with the poll.It is poorly worded.If you are to have voting option C.then you should have had voting option D 'I would be happy to fish with both'
As stated A is more a stillwater pattern and B is a river type of pattern.

Jim

[sabalos]

sorry its poorly worded. did not think i would get the post to work at all.
especially as my four year old son is demanding my attention every minute!
and i managed to shrink the photos in photoshop to upload them.
serves me right for feeling smug....

no offense taken , dave

[Chris Reeves]

I agree, I'd fish both on the same cast in rivers or lakes, Spider on a dropper, Buzzer on the point.

Cheers