John ,
if you search the net - necks vs saddles.. you will find that necks tend to vary from tiny at the top of the head to large at the shoulder. These are suitable for tiny to huge dry flies
Saddles tend to be of uniform size in the top genetic product eg 14+16 or 12+14 or 16+18 with a few outside that range
If you want to tie lots of different sizes, get a neck.
If you tie commercially and want 14-16 get a suitable saddle.
The problem your friend will encounter with chinese hackle is due to import restrictions from the far east due to bird flu; and with finding consistent quality in that product. He will then have to take cream/white capes and dye them to our preference. These are generally used for salmon flies in any case, so are really not what you'd want for trout dry flies. They are however just what you would want for salmon flies and lake flies.
Genetic capes from the US have no such problem, they are easily controlled re- quality and uniformity and are generally available.
The Collins necks are a steal at that price. The quality is excellent in my view.
The grade 3 is excellent! buy one and if you don't like I'll take it off you at cost+postage.
I would forget all about the assorted dozen from ebay, you want to handle the goods or seriously trust the supplier.
Considering that - the link to Jim's custom flies as posted by Lighthouse should take you to Jim Slattery, whom you should be able to trust implicitly, as you can trust Cookshill and the products of Mr Collins and Mr Whiting.
These guys are trying to build and/or maintain a reputation, thus they want you to be happy so you return to the shop.
Enough from me, - don't spend too much
Buy a grizzly dyed golden olive, a badger and a red game/coachman neck, if these are just for you... tie some flies and do some good fishing.
All the best from an Antrim man in London,
Roy
Quote:
Originally Posted by flyfishing 4 life
Hi roy, cheers for your post..I agree it does seem like good value...
and the chinese capes at 12 euros seem to be a steal too.. but as i said irishflycraft seem to have a problem with supplying the chinese dyed capes.....
Are these chinese dyed capes so cheap because they arent good quality capes for tying?? or would they be good enough?
one last thing, there are collins saddles for 20 euros and collins necks for 25 euros. .whats the difference>???
http://www.irishflycraft.com/tying-m...als-page.html#
cheers
John |
flytying capes...
Linear Mode
