Hi, Im well accustomed to dying with veniards dye's and have always got the desired result with them. However, a few months back I attempted to use a womens hair dye as I was informed that it worked perfectly.
Long story short, I managed to ruin a perfectly good cream Bronze Grade Hebert Miner rooster half saddle. I bought a colour which was a kind of fiery red on the pack but, the saddle turned a colour which looked more like a dull pink lol. Even if the colour had come out the shade I'd hoped it still would have been useless as the back face of all the feathers stayed cream.........ive actually made some crazyass flies out of this cape
ive also used dylon dyes and in my opinion they're ok for cheap capes and saddles but if you're dying genetics just go for the acid dye every time, they penetrate much better and dont really cost much more than womens hair dye's anyway