Looking for some feedback

[chirpyaphid]

Here are a couple of flies tied over the weekend. Looking for some feedback and comments.

Fly A:




Fly B:

[x dave x]

Have you used different hooks, Fly A looks odd around the thorax or is it just the photo angle?

Dave

Nicely dressed both flies

[chirpyaphid]

They are tied on two different hooks. Fly A is on a Guru QM1 #14 and Fly B is on an Emerger #12

[dabhoy]

Both flies are well tied as far as Im concened
Im not sure that the 1st hook is the best for what you are tying but I could be wrong I would also have made the body a little longer

[lochkinbrek]

the will catch fish for sure

[T.K]

The only thing i can see wrong with these is you haven't sent me a couple.....

Nice one........ Tony.........

[chirpyaphid]

Originally Posted by dabhoy

Both flies are well tied as far as Im concened
Im not sure that the 1st hook is the best for what you are tying but I could be wrong I would also have made the body a little longer

Agreed that the body for Fly A should possibly be a bit longer and I plan on tying one to see what the difference looks like. Now just need to wait till pay day for going out and giving these a test and see how they perform.

Chirpy

PS thanks to everyone for the feedback so far.

[maharg]

Not much wrong with them mate.
Would question the weight of the first hook though, looks a little "meaty"
ATB
Graham

[Bigfoot]

Personally I would have fly 2 with a slimmer body then the thorax area would be more apparent.

Also a turn or two less of hackle on both flies would be my choice.



Dave

[wye_wizard]

the hook on the first fly looks odd, apart from that they are really well tied. jon.