I haven't tried any of Toby's stuff or EP for that matter... On naturals it is hard to beat Icelandic Sheep (no they aren't a bunch of bankers

) and Bucktail... mixed with a bit of sparkly stuff... coincedentally Barry Reynolds swears by the stuff and my pike haven't complained!!!
I'd quite like to mix some of Toby's stuff in with it to bulk up and give tandems extra volume... I've only started tying but have a couple of creations on my blog... for folk to crit... pike aren't as discerning as trout!!