I can only second your thoughts guys. The honory baliff's on the Water of Leith advise the council on their fishing policy - unfortunately they speak a load of pish

This year I fished the "burn" on four occasions, I was stoped and asked for my permit three times which is equivalent to the amount of times I've been asked in 30 plus years of fishing the place! It was good to see the river being policed, god knows it needs it. However, I was not impressed by the baliffs - on one occasion I came across one knocking back a few cans of "super ****" while taking in the cricket at Roseburn Park, on another I came across their head honcho (I think) who I quizzed a little about the stocking policy. His tale went something like this:-
Electro fishing has proved that there is not enough juvenile trout in the water and, what with the introduction of grayling, causing additional competition the trout would all die out if they didn’t put some fish in! In fact they have only put 2300 trout in (over 14 miles of water) when the scientist tell them they should really be stocking 3000 fish to maintain a viable population.
Obvious pish! In the past the wild trout have managed to survive stockings of Rainbows, Brookies, Brownies, pollution incidents galore and hordes of bait and fly anglers. Sure they were challenging to catch but that was why they surrived. I doubt the current policy of polluting the water with bigger stocked fish will eradicate the native fish but the competition is obviously driving them to the "wilder" places at the top of the river. I have to admit that I like fishing in the heart of the city (probably something to do with living in rural Perthshire) when I visit and I'd hate to see it turning into a some sort of stockie only river. Maybe the grayling will turn out to be its saving grace
Wee Jimmy, we must have spent a lot of time fishing the same places - Saughton was my local stretch, I fished it heavily through the late 70's & 80's and early 90's
Norm