Quote:
Originally Posted by wrongfoot
I understand that the line weight is chosen to match the size of the fly in order to have enough energy to turn it over.
Why would you want one of these? What fishing task does it fulfill better than a normal 3wt at 10ft or less or a 12ft plus normal 9wt salmon rod? What are you targeting?
I'm suspicious that this is a case of the Emperor's New Clothes, but I'm witholding judgement until I learn more.
|
First, there isn't a single 'spey cast' that you can't do with a one hander rod. Some are just a bit of a pain to properly execute (snake roll for one); the rest are darned easy with a tad of practice.
But what is a 'spey cast?' Any spey cast? Just a change of direction cast that eliminates all the false casting generally required with a one hander to accomplish a 'change in line direction.' Add to that, you need only a minimal amount of 'clear air' around/behind you and you'll soon learn why the Scott's 'invented' the rod type/many of the initial casts. (Remember reading someplace that the 'Spey rod' was actually first developed in Wales, but it was the Scott's that popularized this type of equipment.)
'Over here' the light 2-handers are typically called 'Trouter's, Switch Rods (all be it those can be of almost any line weight), etc. With the short heads (generally) used you can cast them in quite close (tip casting) or let them rip out to 90'ish feet with a flick of your wrists (look up 'underhanded' spey casting). Try that with with the tree/brush line 10' behind you ..... save for you're darned good at/love roll casting with a single hander..
As for what fish, the answer runs the scale (and dictates what rod/rods you may use). Here on the Rogue the lighter rods are an excellent match for trout and summer run steelhead (1-5 pounds on average) with low water flows. As the flows go up/fish get larger you'll need heavier equipment. Fishing for these fellows (again, generally) be using 6# leader to the top fly and as low as 4# for the trailer.
As an example we've low flows going on the upper river and a large run of Summer Steelhead. Over lapping that are two major runs of King and Coho Pacific Salmon. Either of those fish could easily go 20 to 30+ pounds. There, anything below a 7wt rod would just be kidding yourself. It would be a 'no contest' after the first few seconds. Leader for these fellows needs to be at least 10 or 12 pound if you're going to have a chance in hell at landing same.
But to your "Emperor's New Clothes" analogy, would you use a 7-9 wt rod to chase 1 pound trout? Or conversely, would you use a 3wt if you were fishing for Atlantic Salmon?
fae
Edit: Should have added I just added a 12'5" five weight (Anderson Custom Rods) to the collection. But what the hell, I'm a 'tackle tart' at heart.